- Rev. George Newton 1815-1840
- Rev. Alfred Henry Dashiell 1841-1856
- Rev. John Henry Bryson 1868-1872
- Rev. John Franklin Cannon 1881-1888
- Rev. William Crawford Clark 1889-1897
- Rev. Donald MacQueen 1906-1916
- Rev. James Frances Tappey 1918-1921
- Rev. Jerome Pillow Robertson 1922-1926
- Rev. Julian Scales Sibley 1927-1932
- Rev. Noah Julian Warren 1933-1939
- Rev. Charles Garnett Bruce 1940-1946
- Rev. William Adolphus James 1946-1951
- Rev. Adrian George Kolean 1951-1958
- Rev. Robert Eugene Cogswell 1959-1978
- Rev. Kenneth R. Ford 1980-1990
- Rev. Gordon A. Turnbull 1991-1999
- Rev. Leslie Glover-Associate 1996-1998
- Rev. Stephen Rhoads Caine 2000-present
- Rev. Lindsey Wade-Associate 2006-present
|
